If you’re looking for Colbinabbin’s AFL superstar, don’t ask Ben McEvoy for directions.
Hold tight - we’re checking permissions before loading more content
Because the two-time premiership player loves his new hometown and he’s happily retreated there to leave all the hoopla behind him and do what he’s always dreamed.
Be a farmer.
In a little country town of a few hundred people, where McEvoy is the bloke next door, one of the guys in the local tennis team, just another dad at the primary school.
In his day, McEvoy ruled the ruck at the back end of Hawthorn’s famous three-peat — being part of its 2014 and 2015 flags.
But ask him about that and you will discover he is way more excited about being accepted as a de facto local by the community (his wife Nicki is the true local) than the locals might have been at his cameo this year, with the seniors on their fairytale way to the finals.
When you meet McEvoy, a towering presence at 200cm, you quickly learn he is not only not defined by AFL accolades, he’s happy to not discuss them at all.
They will always be part of him, but they are also his past.
His life now, and his and his family’s future, is about him being Mr Average.
When we turn up at his house for a chat, McEvoy’s got his work clobber on, his paddock persona. Next on the agenda is heading south to his sheep farm. Before that, his morning has already been part of the rush to school and dropping off all the kids (there’s four of them).
McEvoy has always been busy. The AFL is a demanding master, leaving little time for anything but football — not just playing, but preparing, planning, a routine ruled by regimen, by training, mandated sleep and recovery, diet plans. Relentless. Remorseless.
Then, suddenly, you retire.
No more being part of a machine where your every waking and sleeping hour was tightly controlled and managed.
For McEvoy, as with so many others, just as suddenly there was a lot more time to fill.
Except unlike so many, McEvoy had been planning and he was looking forward to the challenge of being a very ordinary guy with a very ordinary life far, far away from the football goldfish bowl.
“The beauty of my life, but also the thing I find most frustrating, is every day is different,” McEvoy said.
“It’s great because variety’s the spice of life. I don't think I could ever handle a 9am to 5pm job, so it's awesome having something different every day, both on and off the farm.
“The frustrating part is I love to work, but I can’t find enough hours in the week to get my teeth into everything I’d like to.
“But I’m in a very fortunate position.”
McEvoy reckons despite those demands of the AFL, he’s always understood the bigger picture.
“I did a Bachelor of Business while I was playing, which I never used, but I finished it so I could stand in front of my kids one day when they want to quit something and say, ‘no, even your dad finished an online uni degree’,” he said.
“So I was always really strong on that.
“I think AFL players get it too easy. They get locked in this bubble that footy is all there is, and it’s important in my view to encourage guys to pursue something off-field.”
For McEvoy, that was, and is, farming.
He brought his first piece of land at 23, while still playing.
Agriculture was in his blood, growing up on a farm in the small town of Dederang, about 50km south of Wodonga.
And he was always going to revisit those roots.
“You can take a boy out of the country, but you can’t take the country out of the boy,” McEvoy said.
“That was me to a tee. I couldn’t get out of the city quick enough.”
His first foray into farming land was around Stawell and he spent most of his off-seasons there and “kept adding” to it as the years passed.
Until a change of scenery a couple of years ago, when Colbinabbin came into his life and became more than just a location.
A common misconception is that Colbinabbin is his hometown.
That is not quite right.
His dad grew up in Colbo, and he does have family from there.
But McEvoy’s not born and bred, a confusion which amusingly frustrates genuine Colbonites.
Such as his wife.
“She gets very upset when people don’t recognise it’s her hometown, not mine,” McEvoy grinned.
The couple has been together for almost 16 years, ensuring McEvoy frequented Colbo quite a bit even before calling it home.
He says over the time he’s known his wife, a conscious effort was made to get involved in the community as much as possible, starting with a gathering which has become a long-standing family tradition.
Its next instalment is in just over a month’s time.
“I don’t think I’ve missed a Christmas Eve at the Colbo pub for 15 years. I’ve always gone with my father-in-law,” McEvoy said.
One annual meet like this, among other visits, eased him into the local scene.
His motivation to prioritise those connections was sparked by a poignant message during his AFL days.
“At Hawthorn, in the lift at Waverley, there was a quote from Dr Sandy Ferguson, a past president, which said, ‘embrace Hawthorn and Hawthorn will embrace you’,” McEvoy said.
“And I find Colbo very similar. I’ve dived in head-first to connect with people, but it’s also a very special little community which has wrapped its arms around our family, which is really cool.”
McEvoy also saw an opportunity to use his sporting stocks to his advantage in tennis, where he has been a key figure in reigniting Colbo’s senior program, leading to a division two title last season. Now he is Campaspe Tennis Association president.
But footy is always lurking in the background.
A special one-off match in 2023 saw McEvoy play for the Hoppers, a “really cool” moment of sharing the field with his brothers and to carry on a McEvoy legacy — his dad and grandfather are both past premiership players in the green and gold. His cousin Olivia has also won four league medals in netball.
But the 2023 occasion was supposed to be a one-time exception to a rule because McEvoy said he would never play again.
Particularly after 2022.
“In my last year I broke my neck and essentially got away with it, did a full rehab in 13 weeks and got back to playing,” McEvoy said.
“When you’ve got four little kids and you break your neck and can still walk home, open the door and hug them, you think, ‘thank God, I'll take my chance and off I go’.”
But it never quite ends that way.
And going back on his own word is probably the biggest vindication of how McEvoy has been touched by his Colbo community.
He agreed to fill in with the reserves, who were short on numbers.
“Sometimes you get a job on the gate, sometimes you work in the canteen, and sometimes, when you’re still the right side of 40, you pull the boots on and make up the numbers,” he said.
“So that’s how it started, and then (of course) the club asked me about playing enough games to qualify for finals.
“I spoke to my wife about it, and we got a bit sentimental, initially agreed I was supposed to be a back-up, but knew when September came, I would be asked.”
McEvoy played in Colbo’s Heathcote league finals campaign, named in the best in all three matches and kicking five goals before bowing out in the preliminary final. Not even a giant of the AFL game was enough to cut the HDFL mustard.
But, as you might suspect if you’ve read this far, McEvoy didn’t care what his stats were.
He was just happy to be involved, like everyone else.
“It’s about the power of the Colbo community,” McEvoy said.
“I was never going to play footy again for me.
“Because it was for Colbo, all of a sudden, there was a greater meaning which outweighed the risk factor of getting badly injured again.”
So in between the back-and-forth of pick-ups and drop-offs, and the breeding and baling, it’s all about community.
And in country communities, that always means sport.
Which is why, despite tennis and footy, farming and family, McEvoy is now magically manufacturing more time to kick-start a local group fitness initiative.
Just another one of those roles reinforcing his place in the community, his community — and a role he celebrates as much as any premiership.